On insecurity, unsolicited advice, and why some friendships leave you feeling smaller instead of supported.
We’re all insecure about something.
You. Me. Your partner. Your parents. Your children. Your friends.
Perhaps it’s our appearance, our career, our relationships, our intelligence, or the rather uncomfortable feeling that everyone else seems to have figured out something we haven’t.
Which, by the way, they probably haven’t.
Most of us are just making things up as we go along.
And that’s perfectly human.
We’re here to figure things out, make mistakes, learn, grow, and hopefully become a little more comfortable with ourselves along the way.
But here’s the thing about insecurity.
Some people recognise it and try to work through it.
Others seem determined to make it everybody else’s problem.
And that, I think, is where things become unpleasant.
When Insecurity Becomes Everyone Else’s Problem
Insecurity can manifest in all sorts of ways.
Sometimes it’s quiet. A person doubts themselves, worries about being accepted, or struggles to believe they’re good enough.
Other times, it becomes something rather more aggressive.
The need to control people. The constant comparisons. The unsolicited criticism. The peculiar satisfaction some people seem to derive from pointing out what everybody else is doing wrong.
And occasionally, an almost compulsive need to demonstrate superiority.
Over absolutely everything.
You mention a career decision.
They’ve made a better one.
You talk about a holiday.
They’ve been somewhere more interesting.
You share something you’ve learned.
They already knew that, obviously.
How wonderful.
I’m not suggesting that everyone who behaves competitively is secretly insecure. Some people are simply competitive, socially clumsy, or unaware of how they come across.
But when someone repeatedly needs to establish that they’re smarter, stronger, more independent, or somehow more evolved than everyone around them, I start to wonder what they’re trying so hard to prove.
And to whom.
Because genuine confidence rarely requires a running commentary.
The Signs I’ve Learned to Notice
Over time, I’ve begun recognising certain patterns in friendships that feel more competitive than supportive.
Not every behaviour on this list is necessarily a sign of insecurity. Context matters, and we all have our less-than-gracious moments.
But when several patterns appear repeatedly, I pay attention.
1. Every conversation becomes an advertisement for themselves.
You know the type.
“I’m so independent.”
“I’m a very strong person.”
“I’ve always been different from everyone else.”
There’s nothing wrong with being proud of your qualities.
But when someone constantly announces how wonderful they are, particularly while contrasting themselves with supposedly inferior people, the conversation can start to feel less like a friendship and more like a marketing campaign.
And I’m afraid I didn’t subscribe.
2. Their greatest achievements seem to have happened a very long time ago.
They were brilliant at eighteen.
Exceptional at university.
The most impressive person in some organisation fifteen years ago.
And somehow, every conversation finds its way back there.
Now, I love nostalgia. I write about it myself.
But there’s a difference between fondly remembering your past and repeatedly using it to establish your superiority in the present.
Past achievements deserve appreciation.
They don’t have to become permanent evidence that everyone else is beneath you.
3. They make themselves look better by making other people look worse.
Someone chooses employment over entrepreneurship?
Weak.
Someone wants a conventional lifestyle?
Boring.
Someone is more cautious about relationships?
Emotionally underdeveloped.
Apparently, the entire world is divided into people who live correctly and people who don’t.
And wouldn’t you know it?
They always seem to fall into the first category.
I find this particularly revealing because a secure person can recognise that different people want different things.
Not every life needs to resemble yours to be worthwhile.
4. They struggle to be vulnerable.
Some people seem unable to admit uncertainty, embarrassment, mistakes, or moments of weakness.
Every difficulty becomes a story about how brilliantly they handled it.
Every disappointment becomes evidence of someone else’s shortcomings.
And every failure?
Well, apparently, those don’t happen.
Vulnerability isn’t about revealing every private detail of your life. Nobody owes us that.
But healthy friendships generally require some capacity for honesty, accountability, and admitting that we don’t always have everything under control.
Without that, genuine intimacy becomes difficult.
5. They offer advice nobody asked for.
You mention something about your life.
Perhaps you’re not even complaining.
You’re simply telling a story.
And suddenly, you’re receiving a detailed assessment of your personality, choices, emotional state, and what you should be doing differently.
Thank you, I suppose.
But I was telling you about my Tuesday.
Not requesting a psychological evaluation.
Advice can be an act of care. It can also become a way of asserting authority, especially when the person giving it seems uninterested in whether you actually want or need it.
6. Every discussion becomes an opportunity to judge someone.
You talk about a mutual acquaintance.
They begin explaining what’s wrong with that person’s character.
You describe a situation.
They immediately start diagnosing motives, identifying flaws, or announcing what everyone involved should have done.
There’s little curiosity.
Little willingness to consider other interpretations.
Just certainty.
An extraordinary amount of certainty.
And sometimes I wonder whether the constant analysis of other people’s supposed shortcomings is a way of avoiding a closer examination of one’s own.
7. They find it difficult to celebrate you without comparing themselves.
You share good news.
Instead of being happy for you, they change the subject, minimise the achievement, or explain how they’ve accomplished something similar.
Sometimes the response is subtle.
Sometimes it’s so obvious you almost want to laugh.
The point is that your happiness seems to create discomfort rather than delight.
And that’s a difficult foundation for friendship.
The Friendship That Became a Competition
I once had a friend who seemed to view much of life as a competition.
Not an actual competition, mind you.
There were no medals.
No judges.
No finish line.
And, as far as I was aware, nobody else had agreed to participate.
But somehow, the competition continued.
She was self-employed, which she seemed to regard as evidence of being more independent, capable, and successful than people who held conventional jobs.
She frequently talked about how much freedom she had.
How she could arrange her time however she pleased.
How employed people were somehow less independent.
Now, there’s nothing wrong with being proud of running your own business.
It’s difficult work, and I admire people who do it well.
But I couldn’t understand why her satisfaction with her own choices required other people’s choices to be inferior.
Surely you can enjoy being self-employed without needing everyone with an employment contract to feel inadequate?
Apparently, this was a controversial proposition.
There was also a recurring distinction between people she considered “strong” and those she considered “weak”.
She, naturally, belonged to the strong category.
Other people were not always so fortunate.
Over time, I found these conversations increasingly tiresome.
It wasn’t simply that we disagreed.
I enjoy exchanging different opinions. I find it stimulating.
But there’s a difference between discussing ideas and constantly being invited to participate in someone else’s hierarchy of human worth.
Eventually, I stopped engaging as much.
The friendship gradually drifted.
And I was comfortable letting it.
Why Do Some People Need to Win at Friendship?
I suspect social comparison plays a role.
We all compare ourselves with others occasionally.
Sometimes comparison inspires us. We see someone doing something interesting and think, Perhaps I could try that too.
But comparison can also become a way of measuring our worth.
If someone else is successful, does that mean I’m less successful?
If someone else is attractive, does that make me less attractive?
If someone else is happy with a life different from mine, does that somehow threaten the choices I’ve made?
It shouldn’t.
But for people whose self-worth depends heavily on being better than others, another person’s happiness or competence can feel uncomfortable.
Rather than developing a more stable sense of self, they may attempt to restore their position by diminishing someone else.
Of course, we cannot know another person’s inner motivations with certainty.
And insecurity doesn’t automatically make someone unkind.
Many insecure people are thoughtful, sensitive, and deeply considerate.
The issue isn’t insecurity itself.
It’s what someone chooses to do with it.
You Don’t Have to Keep Auditioning for Friendship
So how do you deal with someone like this?
I think the first step is to stop treating every comment as something you must defend yourself against.
If someone believes that entrepreneurship is superior to employment, you don’t have to convince them otherwise.
If they think their lifestyle is the only correct one, you don’t need to present a twenty-slide PowerPoint defending yours.
You can simply disagree.
Or change the subject.
Or decline to participate.
Sometimes a calm response is enough.
“I’m happy with the choice I’ve made.”
“I see it differently.”
“That’s not really something I’m looking for advice on.”
And if the relationship matters to you, it’s worth having an honest conversation about how their behaviour affects you.
Some people genuinely don’t realise how competitive or dismissive they sound.
They may be capable of listening, reflecting, and changing.
Others may respond by becoming even more defensive, critical, or controlling.
That tells you something too.
For me, the deciding factor is often whether the person can take responsibility for their behaviour.
Can they acknowledge that they were hurtful?
Can they be curious about your perspective?
Can they disagree without making you feel inferior?
Can they celebrate your happiness even when your choices are different from theirs?
If the answer is consistently no, I begin to question what the friendship is offering.
Friendship Shouldn’t Require Someone to Lose
I’ve become more selective about the relationships I invest in.
Not because I expect everyone to be perfectly confident, emotionally mature, or endlessly supportive.
Goodness knows none of us are.
But I want friendships where people can be different without turning those differences into rankings.
Where one person’s success doesn’t threaten another person’s worth.
Where we can laugh at ourselves, admit our mistakes, and talk about our lives without every conversation becoming a contest.
I want to be around people who are curious.
People who can disagree without belittling.
People who don’t need to be the smartest, strongest, most successful person in the room.
And people who are genuinely pleased when something wonderful happens to someone else.
Because friendship, to me, isn’t about finding people who are better or worse than you.
It’s about finding people with whom you can simply be yourself.
And if someone insists on turning your friendship into a competition?
Well.
They’re welcome to the trophy.
I wasn’t competing anyway.